Amazon et Jeff Bezos le philanthrope !

If Jeff Bezos is serious about social responsibility, he’ll make Amazon cough up

While the Amazon boss’s hefty donation is welcome, the company has been a factor in the social problems that Bezos is now trying to address.

Amidst rising inequalities and the degradation of hard-won social rights, the ultra-rich salvage their conscience through philanthropy and charitable donations.

The latest billionaire to do so is Jeff Bezos, founder, chairman and chief executive of Seattle-based online retailer Amazon. Bezos is estimated to have wealth of more than $150 billion and has promised to donate $2 billion to fund “existing non-profits that help homeless families, and creating a network of new, non-profit, tier-one preschools in low-income communities”.

The $2 billion represents just over 1% of Bezos’ wealth and considerably less than the taxes avoided by Amazon. This donation comes after Amazon played a key role in defeating a tax by Seattle Council designed to reduce homelessness in the city.

Philanthropy is always welcome, but Amazon has been the author of the social problems that Bezos is now trying to address – homelessness and the state’s inability to develop institutional structures to address that.

Amazon provides jobs but at a price. Harsh working conditions have been reported throughout Amazon’s operations across the world. James Bloodworth, former editor of Left Foot Forward, took an undercover job at Amazon’s UK operations and reported that employees often worked ten and a half hour shifts.

Employees had to march up and down the long narrow aisles picking customer orders from two-metre-high shelves. Over the course of a single day a picker could walk as far as 24 kilometres. Amazon also operated a disciplinary points system which penalised workers for illness and for taking toilet breaks, though it now claims to have abolished such penalties. Employees received the minimum wage and many probably have to rely on food-banks and welfare support to make ends meet.

Amazon employees have been the subject of relentless robotic surveillance and targets. One undercover reporter was told to pack 120 items an hour and that target was set to rise to 200 items. A number of workers who could not cope with the relentless targets were attended to by ambulance crews after they collapsed on the job. Some call centre workers sought to unionise. Amazon responded by shutting down the call centre.

Low wages have enriched Amazon executives and shareholders and sent the share price rocketing, but have also disabled many employees and their families from living fulfilling lives. People may seek help from the state, but Amazon avoids taxes and deprives the state of much needed revenues.

Amazon has been a serial tax avoider. Its global revenues for 2017 topped $179 billion and generated profits of over $3bn, but it paid virtually no corporation tax in the US. Due to complex corporate structures and profit shifting through intragroup transactions, Amazon’s profits in various countries are difficult to ascertain from its annual accounts.

Most recently, it is estimated to have paid UK corporation tax of £1.7m on profits of £72.3m. In 2016, Amazon is estimated to have paid €16.5m (£15m) in tax on European revenues of €21.6bn (£19.5bn) reported through Luxembourg.

Through the ballot-box people can mandate the state to improve social welfare, but companies like Amazon exercise the ultimate veto i.e. they do not pay taxes and billionaire’s like Jeff Bezos end-up negating democratic choices. While unresponsive governments can be voted out of office, people can do little to check corporate power.

Acts of philanthropy may earn some applause, but they cannot provide the systematic basis for tackling social problems.

It takes years to train doctors, nurses and teachers; build hospitals and schools and a vast organisational structure to operate them. It takes considerable time to plan and build houses and related infrastructure, or provide institutional framework to eradicate homelessness.

This requires responsive institutional structures and a steady supply of finance. No government can commit to a long-term programme of education, healthcare or house building on the basis of philanthropy of billionaires. If the mood of the billionaire changes and s/he halts donations, all that is built upon charity will inevitably collapse.

The charitable whims of billionaires do not provide the durable basis for building institutional frameworks necessary for eradicating social problems.

Despite all its contradictions, the state remains the major institution capable of responding to citizens’ demands and building durable institutional structures to address social problems. Yet its capacity to act is routinely undermined by companies like Amazon.

If Bezos is really serious about addressing social problems then he does not have to look far. Amazon could develop policies for more equitable sharing of wealth. It should increase wages and improve working practices. To ensure that workers’ perspectives inform company decisions and halt exploitative practice, Amazon should have workers on its board. It can stop shifting profits and pay taxes where the revenue is generated.

In an ideal world, wealthy elites would reflect on the links between social problems and their intoxication with private wealth, status and power. Alas, there is little sign of that.

Prem Sikka is Professor of Accounting at University of Sheffield and Emeritus Professor of Accounting at University of Essex. He tweets here.

More from Lobbies

La Suisse et les lanceurs d’alerte – Que signifierait l’acquittement de R.Elmer ? – Les juges suisses cherchent à élargir le secret bancaire à l’étranger – Remise en cause suisse de l’échange automatique d’informations ? – Elmer promet de livrer ses documents si on le blanchit – Trutheum : la récompense pour les lanceurs d’alerte ! – Le coût de toutes ces poursuites … – Elmer gagne contre un journal d’extrême droite (UDC) – Création d’une plate-forme africaine de protection des lanceurs d’alerte – Récupérer les données livrées par les lanceurs d’alerte – La protection des lanceurs d’alerte – Luxembourg, les plaidoiries et la contestation de la « bonne foi » – 6 mois pour Deltour et une amende pour Halet ? – A Luxembourg, ce 12 décembre, le procès reprend en appel et avec les ONG – Lanceurs d’alerte contre secret des affaires – une loi et une pétition en France – les condamnés de Luxleaks iront en appel – Coupables ou héros, les lanceurs d’alerte ? Une « Brève » de Kairos Europe WB

read more

Panama Papers – le cabinet Mossack Fonseca ferme ses portes – débat et vote au PE les 12 et 13 décembre – Belfius perquisitionné – le rapport de la Commission du Parlement européen – Au parlement belge : des conclusions disputées … – Il y a un an, les Panama Papers … – le Conseil européen, sous la présidence de Malte, renonce à tirer les conclusions et à poursuivre le blanchiment d’argent -l’OLAF ouvre 6 enquêtes sur des responsables européens – les circuits de la finance opaque (C.Chavagneux) – le site de la gauche (GUE) européenne et celui de la Commission parlementaire européenne – Subvention pour sachets de lait en Algérie et paradis fiscaux – Stiglitz dénonce Panama lui-même – un magnat du pétrole nigérian épinglé – Mossack devant le parlement européen – Stiglitz démissionne du comité créé par le Panama – en Afrique – au G-20 – aux USA – l’Afrique touchée … – Panama, 98° pays à signer l’échange d’informations – dans l’UE et au Parlement européen – 1580 sociétés offshore déclarées en tout au fisc belge – l’enquête en France – 117 intermédiaires belges – riches américains – commerce des armes – au Parlement belge – la Suisse en tête – Algérie – 65 diamantaires belges

read more

Soros, le Brexit et l’hypocrisie du Daily Mail – La malédiction des ressources financières : la Suisse – Brexit – la City et ses chambres de compensation – Barnier au Luxembourg – Mc Donald’s quitte le Luxembourg pour Londres et bénéficier de 17% d’impôt sur les sociétés -les banques de la City s’apprêtent à chercher domiciliation ailleurs – la livre sterling et malédiction des ressources – les entreprises financières britanniques et leur assaut à Bruxelles

read more

Les USA : des dispositions anti OMC avec la nouvelle loi fiscale, un soutien à l’offshore et à Apple … – leurs Etats – avec l’Union européenne alors qu’un deal fiscal est négocié entre républicains et démocrates – toujours le Delaware – les 500 plus grosses sociétés détiennent 2.400 milliards $ dans les paradis fiscaux et évitent ainsi pour 695 milliards $ d’impôts …

read more

Amazon, Apple et la Commission européenne – L’Irlande refuse de réclamer 13 milliards $ à Apple (qui défie également l’Europe), elle s’oppose ainsi à la Commission européenne – Apple lance son Iphone 7, c’est avec l’argent du contribuable , boycottez-le ! – Amazon s’adapte et change ses lieux d’implantation en Europe – Apple : ce mardi 30 août, la Commission européenne impose une amende de 13 milliards – 215 milliards $ en trésorerie – lance un emprunt pour 12 milliards $, devinez pourquoi …? Tim Cook fait du lobbying à Bruxelles

read more